Created by a human, with a brain badgeA badge with a character next to the text "Web 14," indicating that the site may contain slightly offensive materialDo What The Fuck You Want To Public License badgeTrans flag badgemi toki e Toki Ponamade with MY OWN TWO PAWS badgeNo cookies badgeNo tracking or analytics badgeMade with server-side scripting badgeHosted on home internet badge


Affini, Parenting, and Suicide

I recently came across the Human Domestication Guide setting and it gave me a whole lot of Thoughts that I think I have resolved into something mostly cohesive.
A good point to start is with the following:
  • Voluntary domestication, even resulting in identity death or a loss of personhood altogether, is unproblematic
  • Enticing someone to submit to domestication or incentivizing domestication is immoral
  • Non-consentual domestication is ???

Parenting

I struggled quite a bit with how I felt about non-consentual domestication. The obvious answer, of course, is "no consent = feel bad," but in most stories the Affini are good. Both good in a general sense, and good at what they do. With the suspension of disbelief of the fantasy setting most stories would imply that 100% of domesticated people are happy that they were domesticated. This, along with what I saw as clear parallels (sometimes explicit parallels 💀) to being raised by parental figures that lay down rules we do not consent to, muddies the waters.

Ah, but the children do not know better, and their brains are not developed yet. In ten or twenty years, regardless of whether we ignored their wishes, they would look back and agree that it would have been the right decis-. . . oh. Well, that's the same scenario the Affini say they are in, isn't it? s/older/free from stress/. Is raising a child immoral because they both require limits, and the support you give them cannot be without cultural influence? (note - things can be immoral and still worth doing)

Suicide

I am not suicidal but probably think about it waaaay more than the people who care about me would say is OK, so of course it was the next analogy my brain went to. Assisted suicide is currently rapidly expanding in Canada and still a divisive topic, but one that I hope I can work backwards from. I won't make a case for it, but here is one thing to read if you are against it.

The government (society insert ghost noises) should have no say on the right to suicide of a person who is terminally ill or has a low quality of life that cannot be meaningfully risen. If they are of sound mind and say that the cost of living is too high for the life they have left to live, they should be allowed to end their life.

I would argue that Canada's requirement of "[having] a grievous and irremediable medical condition" is unreasonable. We do not consent to be brought into this world, and though I find it to be worthwhile for the heck of it, others may not - and not expect that to change, or not want to put in the effort of changing it. If they are of sound mind, they should be allowed to end their life. Society can say that it is owed a debt, but one cannot sign another up for infinite debt. Reproduction is a roll of the dice, and parents and society need to respect that, choose their actions accordingly, and accept the consequences if their bet doesn't pay off; children owe nothing to anyone.

Thirdly - and this is where it gets spicy - I think that anyone without any medical conditions, who are not of sound mind, should also be allowed to end their life. This is actually the same scenario as the previous. In both the moral opposition comes from the fact that they might, if they lived, look back and say that they are glad they did not die then. In this case that possibility is often closer (their state of mind may be temporary) or could be elicited with therapy or drugs to "fix" their state of mind. "You will regret it later, so we (who Know Better), will exert our power over you" and "you will agree with me once you _____" are very dangerous baseis to make decisions on. They can be used to justify anything, and are often featured in authoritarian / dystopian / horror stories. Even if those are correct I consider them to be horrifying denials of one's right to self-determination, but they also may not be - and who are we to say that one's possible future wants (which we estimate, or from which we have cherry-picked) are worth more than the explicit ones they have now?
If I want to understand an individual human being, I must lay aside all scientific knowledge of the average man and discard all theories in order to adopt a completely new and unprejudiced attitude.
– Carl Jung, The Undiscovered Self

Ha! Would you look at that! We're right back where we started! The Affini and enforcing domestication is the same moral question as preventing suicide. I find it comforting that the problem is just as difficult when it is regarding bliss rather than the weighty topic of suicide.
I may have lost you there, and that could be a place where we fundamentally disagree (some people are in favor of forced hospitalization even in the cases where it generally leads to terrible outcomes), but I am going to start working backwards now.

Also, note that this trail wasn't meaningless. I at first thought that I had just found my way to an analogous topic I already have more concrete opinions on, but this isn't the same problem as non-consentual domestication. The unchanging certain future wants are on opposite sides. With domestication, ignoring consent leads to one certainly being content with the events that took place, forever. With suicide, respecting consent leads to one certainly being content with the events that took place at the time of them, and "forever." It is clear to me that we should not weigh possible future opinions over current and certain future ones (if the current ones are respected). We can't bounce right back to domestication because the certain future opinions conflict with the current ones - so which is more important? That question is less black and white if the current ones would lead to an "objectively" worse outcome for the individual than the non-consentual certain future ones.

Aside

Enticing people over and incentivizing domestication are a halfway point that I am even less sure of how to approach.

Back to Parenting

I already did not intend to have kids, but I think this is yet another reason for me to not do so. I know that I would struggle with where to draw the line when to compromise between respecting someone's agency and preventing easily avoided mistakes. 18 years is 20-25 percent of life expectancy, going off of the 15yo stats - that is a long time. Honestly, thinking on this has made me a lot more interested in youth rights than anything else; the Affini are only theoretical after all. (Silent tear)
Yes, going straight to talking about the right to suicide is a stretch, but I tend to get upset about local minima. See Immigration, Manifesto, Why I Am Not On Discord.

Closing

Kink incentives aside, HDG is a horror setting, and my impression has been that not many people cherry-pick the stories with less squick. Even with the abuse of one's consent, agency, body, and self that is inherent in many stories, the situations depicted are still alluring. The hurt that comes with being transgender and/or disabled is intense, and the world abuses us because of those attributes constantly. Trading that abuse even for this one that most people would view as horrifying is, as a trade-off, overall comforting to many. I am not into most of the relevant kinks at all; it is just that being able to immerse myself not only in a world where my struggles are not present, but where they are addressed, is something that no other work has offered.